Singapore is my no-choice country ....
I only read from the blogosphere. I don't relish paying for a copy of the Straits Times to have them tell this forty-year-old aunty how to live her life. I found these instructions very familiar:
1 The internet is dangerous because one may be misled by big bad wolves disguised as pro- active citizens writing for the good of the nation.
2 One must be resilient to solve problems on his own.
I remembered dishing out similar advice to my son when he was about ten. Then, I reminded him that we must be vigilant against big bad wolves that prey on children. Time flies. Before you know it, your son was telling you not to waste time reading LKY's memoirs for a similar reason to the first above.
I also told him he had to do his homework without my help. Fast forward another 10 years, I was glad he did not cite the second reason when I asked him to solve my computer problems. Like I have commented somewhere, I did regret reading those memoirs. But that's not the point here.
As with any National Day in any year, the issue of loyalty and emigration would be discussed ad nauseum by Singaporeans. This is the time to head for Xiaxue's blog for a breath of fresh air.
To me, Singapore is my no-choice country. From young, I have been told Singapore is small and lacks resources. But, hey, I am born here ... no choice. So, I grew up accepting many no-choice realities around me.
We have to excel in our studies ... no choice. Unless you want to sweep the roads.
We must be bilingual ... no choice. Unless you want to skip University studies.
We must study science and engineering ... no choice. Unless you want to become an Arts teacher.
We must accept the yearly transport hikes ... no choice. Unless you can control the oil price.
We must accept the casinos ... no choice. Unless you want economic doom.
We must accept the PAP government ... no choice. Unless you find a better opposition.
We must drink recycled water ... no choice. Unless you want to die of thirst.
We must acccept Foreign talents ... no choice. Unless you are able to contribute to the economy like Bill Gates.
We must accept whatever given as best ... no choice. Unless and until 66.6% becomes 33.3%.
Luckily, I am no babe in the woods. I know how to keep my sanity intact within my small personal space. Unlike some mentioned in Xenoboy's '21 grams'.
The trick is to comfort myself that I am not alone in having no choice mah. Look at those no-choice PRs who need to be stuck here for a while before moving on to greener pastures. They are quite similar to those no-choice transit tourists at the Changi Airport too.
The good thing about having no choice left is that, it signals a time to make U-turns and to think of the unthinkable. You wouldn't want to keep moving on till you bang into the wall of a cul de sac, right?
I am not a prophet of any sort. Never would I have, in my earlier years, prophesized that Singapore would one day welcome gambling in a big way (not 1 but 2 casinos!). Wonder how many of my generation did ....
I like having no choice. It is fun to see what goodies come after having no choice.
Singapore, country
19 Comments:
At 7:26 PM, nofearSingapore said…
Hi Whispers,
Most people live their lives where they were born.
Only a small minority ( the well-heeled and the desperate) actually make the step of migrating.
I empathise with both groups- those who leave and those who don't. To each his own.
Singapore is not the best place in the world, neither is it the worst.
If we want a better Sg, we have to do our part to change it.
The people are too contented now to make any drastic moves to change the status quo.
The time will come when more "middle-of-the-roaders" like you and I feel speak up to say that we want something else, only when there is a critical mass from the middle ground, will the authorities listen.
They know that in the meantime, the vast majority are lulled into complacency and inaction as long as they have a chance to get their 5 C's. S'poreans are materialists!
Happy Weekend,
Dr.Huang Shoou Chyuan
At 8:55 PM, Whispers from the heart said…
In the past, I had no complaints living in Singapore.
After 40 years, I think we owe our future generations a legacy of choice.
As the pioneers, we take our lot with pride and understading of our limitations. We forged on.
It is very sad that several generations later, we still cannot afford some choice to our young.
Yes, I hope for some changes in the country. Even if, it's for the selfish reason that my descendants will live here.
Thanks, Dr Huang.
At 12:03 AM, nofearSingapore said…
Hi,
We can give our own children a choice. Discuss with them the realities around them ( economic/political/social).Don't let them just part of the rat race.
I try to let them fulfil their full potential with music ( all sorts-pop/hiphop) and other non-acedemic pursuits.
We are truly "citizens of the world"-Socrates. Sg does not have to be your default choice. Stay here only if you want to. I tell my kids that life is so short, if one day they feel that only going abroad will get them self-actualisation , then go.
But I have no illusions that the grass is truly greener on the other side.
It is for some and ain't for others.
In the meantime, we should do something, even if it is just "ranting" in our blogs!
Cheers
Dr.H
At 1:02 PM, le radical galoisien said…
But in the end for third culture kids like me, it's not simply a matter of leaving or staying ... but trying to bring both worlds into one place. So suggesting I leave for a better place (I do think of myself as a world citizen) - well I already am outside Singapore, but I find no roots here.
Also I learnt more from my secondary school Arts teachers than I did from my secondary school science teachers, and kindled in me the fire (or shall I say dream) of impressionism. So "unless you want to be an arts teacher" doesn't sound that bad.
At 6:20 PM, Whispers from the heart said…
John, it's true.
We need the humanities more than ever in this modern and complicated world.
During my time, well, that's the sad reality. Arts students are not highly 'valued'.
At 12:10 AM, Bernard Leong said…
Hi Whisper,
I think the "no-choice" is a self-imposed. Most Singaporeans do not have a passion and drive to pursue what they believe. That is the reason why they can accept the social compact with tonnes of complaints.
Only when one can move forward with his or her own vision, that is when we have a choice.
Best regards,
BL
At 2:48 AM, Anonymous said…
We are very lucky to be born here. Go figure
At 6:21 AM, En and Hou said…
The worst thing that can happen, is when destiny is often disguised as having "choices"...
Cheers,
Hou
At 8:11 AM, Anonymous said…
since when the broad way is ever not a choice for consuming locusts?..:)
At 9:18 AM, James said…
we have lots of choices lor. just that you have to open your eyes to find them.
instead of just following blindly, you can ask, "why?", and think of an alternative.
then you got choice liao.
At 12:58 AM, Anonymous said…
We as Singaporeans have to shoulder part of the responsibility for the lack of choices.
Yes, our system provides Singaporeans with limited choices in some respects e.g. education - Singapore citizens must go to govt/aided schools unless get permission from MOE to go International School. e.g. housing - your choice is based on your income level, e.g. jobs - paper qualifications rank very high for entry level positions due to our "meritocratic" system.
But we need to exercise our own freedom to choose and to think deeper about the "standard choices". Thinking out-of-the-box and living your life that way is tougher than accepting the default choice. But we do have a choice, we need to consciously think, decide and go for choices other than the default "beige"
Lunatic_fringe
At 12:09 AM, Anonymous said…
At least in Toowoomba, we had the choice over whether we accepted a proposal to put recycled water in our drinking watersystem.
The proposal called for 25-29% recycled water compared to Singapore at 1%.
The proposed plant would not however have worked.
It is not possible to produce 11,000 ML of recycled water from 8,000 ML of sewage. Toowoomba City Council also had nowhere for the RO waste stream to go. Acland Coal did not want it. Singapore pumps its RO waste stream into the sea.
The plant could never have been built for $68 million - closer to $150-200 million would be more accurate when you take into account the hundreds of acres of evaporation ponds required which were not included in the budget.
Regardless of your view on recycled water use, the no vote in Toowoomba was correct because the proposal was a dud.
At 2:10 AM, Whispers from the heart said…
There! Goes to show that the gahmen may not be right always ....
Good to know toowomba residents are smart.
Can't say the same for Singaporeans.
:(
At 12:33 AM, the spear carrier said…
Yah, all of us Singapore Citizens have no choice, as protraited by local media "influenced" by ruling party.
Btw, about your "1 of the 4,000,000 units of Singapore Inc..." self-description. Do u know that the 4 millions Singaporean numbers includes Singapore PR, and only 2.1 millions are Singapore Citizens who have no choice?
At 6:47 PM, Whispers from the heart said…
Those PRs also 'no choice' lah. If they could, they would be in USA, Canada and Australia....
So, they had no choice but to come here but they could still go back.
2.1 million of us just got no choice, period.
At 7:22 PM, Unknown said…
you have a choice. you can leave.
on the other hand. the 'no choice' thing does go well for those people who are too lazy to think for themselves.
At 8:15 PM, the spear carrier said…
Those PRs does have a choice, and that's WHY they have chosen to remain as a PR and not convert to citizen. They are using Singapore as the perfect stepping stone to go into US & UK. We gave them the best opportunities to gain recognised working experience and pick up English, all at the expenses of Singapore Govt funded by Singapore citizens.
Their next choice is to remain in Singapore and see if things work out fine, else, they will abandon ship and take the 3rd choice, return to their home country.
Many of the Singapore Citizens really have no choice cos the ruling party is blocking out the choices by creating GRC and high election deposit rates. Half of the 2.1 million citizens have walkover in their GRC during last election. No need to vote cos they have NO CHOICE...
Cheers.
p.s. I think you should really write to Dr. Chee, not to apologise but to encourage him. He is facing quite a lonely and long battle against the ruling party. It is not our fault for believing less in his character and motives, for these were the false images protraited by local media.
At 2:10 AM, Whispers from the heart said…
Hi spears,
I'll take up your suggestion. It had been on my mind for a long while.
Cheers too.
At 9:30 AM, Anonymous said…
No choice indeed.
We are a over-engineered, overly controlled nation, without a soul. Apart from efficiency, a clean and safe country, I'm afraid we have little else to be truly proud of.
We are given little or no choice and are never encourage to look for or demand choices.
4 million smiles and instant garden along the roads leading to Suntec City for the WTO meeting, not to mention all the sprucing up leading to the VIP walk-abouts we are now very accustomed to.
Dr H is right. Singapore is not the worst nor the best. That's what I used to subscribed to and defend Singapore with when visiting Americans complain about how restrictive(chewing gum) and tyrannical(canning and death penalties) our country is.
Dr H is right again when he said that we have to do something if we want a better SG. Let's hope more people see it the same way and we will have our critical mass sooner rather than later.
Post a Comment
<< Home